desalination facilities and brine disposal
On May 6th, 2015, the State Water Resources Control Board (State Water Board) approved an amendment to the state’s Water Quality Control Plan for the Ocean Waters of California (Ocean Plan) to address effects associated with the construction and operation of seawater desalination facilities (Desalination Amendment). The amendment supports the use of ocean water as a reliable supplement to traditional water supplies while protecting marine life and water quality. The desalination amendment will for the first time, provide a uniform, consistent process for permitting of seawater desalination facilities statewide. In doing so, it provides direction for regional water boards when permitting new or expanded facilities, and provides specific implementation and monitoring and reporting requirements.
Desalination facilities and brine disposal were identified as Issue Number 4 in the 2011-2013 Triennial Review Workplan because several new desalination facilities have been planned along the California coast to augment existing water supplies. The operation and construction of seawater desalination facilities can result in marine life mortality and harm to aquatic life beneficial uses. During the process of ocean desalination, organisms may be drawn in with the source water and enter the facility’s water processing system. Salt and minerals are removed from salt water to produce fresh water and organisms do not survive the desalination process. The salt, minerals, and other compounds produced as a by-product of desalination are discharged into the ocean as hyper-saline brine. Brine is denser than the receiving ocean water and, depending on discharge methods, may settle on the seafloor and have adverse effect on marine organisms.
The Desalination Amendment requires new or expanded seawater desalination plants to use the best available, site, design, technology, and mitigation measures feasible to minimize intake and mortality of all forms of marine life. Based on the best available science, the amendment identifies preferred technologies; however, alternative intake and disposal methods can be used if demonstrated to be as protective of marine life as the preferred technologies. Additionally, mitigation measures are required in order to address damage to marine life that occurs after the best available site, design, and technology feasible are used. Determining whether or not a site, design, technology, and mitigation measure is feasible considers whether something is capable of being accomplished in a successful manner within a reasonable period of time, and takes into account economic, environmental, social, and technological factors.
- The Office of Administrative Law approved the Desalination Amendment on January 28, 2016.
- Final Desalination Amendment – Adopted on May 6, 2015 Final Staff Report and Final Desalination Amendment, including the Final Substitute Environmental Documentation
- The Office of Administrative Law approved the Desalination Amendment on January 28, 2016.
- Board Meeting - Consideration of Adoption of the Proposed Desalination Amendment – May 6, 2015
- Staff Presentation - Claire Waggoner
- May 5, draft Final Desalination Amendment reflecting all changes since March 20, 2015, including revisions in Change Sheet #1 and Change Sheet #2.
- Change Sheet #2
- Change Sheet #1
- Revised Notice
- Public Notice
- Redline/Strikeout draft Final Desalination Amendment - April 24, 2015 version
- Fact Sheet
- April 24, 2015 Draft Final Staff Report with Draft Final Substitute Environmental Documentation:
Document Link Description SR/SED Sections 1 to 13 April 24, 2015 version showing changes from the March 20, 2015 version in strikeout and underline. Appendix A Ocean Plan with the proposed Desalination Amendment and other non-substantive changes in blue strikeout or underline Appendix B Environmental Checklist Appendix C Tables of Life History Information on Select California Marine Organisms Appendix D Summary Tables of Entrainment Studies Appendix E Guidance Documents for Assessing Entrainment Including Additional Information on the Following Loss Rate Models: Fecundity Hindcasting (FH), Adult Equivalent Loss (AEL) and Area Production Forgone using an Empirical Transport Model (ETM/APF) Appendix F Summary Tables of Salinity and Brine Studies Appendix G Economic Analysis Appendix H Response to Public Comments received by August 19, 2014 Appendix I Responses to External Scientific Peer Review Comments Appendix J Response to Public Comments received by April 9, 2015
- Redline/Strikeout draft Final Desalination Amendment - March 20, 2015 version
- March 20, 2015 Draft Final Staff Report with Draft Final SED:
Document Link Description SR/SED Sections 1 to 13, March 20, 2015 version showing changes from the July 3, 2014 version in strikeout and underline. Appendix A Ocean Plan with the proposed Desalination Amendment and other non-substantive changes in blue strikeout or underline Appendix B Environmental Checklist Appendix C Tables of Life History Information on Select California Marine Organisms Appendix D Summary Tables of Entrainment Studies Appendix E Guidance Documents for Assessing Entrainment Including Additional Information on the Following Loss Rate Models: Fecundity Hindcasting (FH), Adult Equivalent Loss (AEL) and Area Production Forgone using an Empirical Transport Model (ETM/APF) Appendix F Summary Tables of Salinity and Brine Studies Appendix G Economic Analysis Appendix H Response to Public Comments Received by August 19, 2014 Appendix I Responses to External Scientific Peer Review Comments
- Public Hearing - August 19, 2014
- Public Notice
- Proposed Desalination Amendment and Draft Staff Report, including the Draft Substitute Environmental Documentation – July 3, 2014
- Presentation 8/19/14 - Claire Waggoner, SWRCB
- Revised Presentation 8/22/14 - Claire Waggoner, SWRCB
- Public Workshop - August 6, 2014
- Public Workshop – September 23, 2013
Amendments to the Water Quality Control Plans for Ocean Waters to Address Desalination Facilities and Brine Disposal
- Stakeholder Meeting at Moss Landing Marine Laboratories – January 30, 2013
Discuss amendments to the Water Quality Control Plans for Ocean Water and Enclosed Bays and Estuaries to Address Desalination Facilities and Brine Disposal
- Public Workshop – August 22, 2012
Amendments to the Water Quality Control Plans for Ocean Waters and Enclosed Bays and Estuaries to Address Desalination Facilities and Brine Disposal
- CEQA Scoping Meeting – March 30, 2012
- Stakeholder Meeting – April 18, 2011
Scientific Peer Review
Pursuant to Health and Safety Code section 57004, the proposed Desalination Amendment and draft Staff Report, including the draft Substitute Environmental Document, were subject to external scientific peer review through an interagency agreement with the University of California. Peer review was solicited on June 18, 2014 and was completed on September 17, 2014. Responses to External Scientific Peer Review comments can be found in Appendix I of the draft Final Staff Report with draft Final SED associated with the draft Final Desalination Amendment.
State Water Board Contracted Expert Panels and Studies
As part of the development of the amendment, staff has initiated four studies to gather scientific data and get technical input and scientific recommendations on key desalination issues. The three expert panels have finalized their findings and recommendations and an additional salinity toxicity study has also been completed.
Expert Panel III on Intake Impacts and Mitigation
The Expert Review Panel on Intake Impacts and Mitigation was reconvened to address the questions raised at the January 30, 2013 Stakeholder Meeting at Moss Landing Marine Laboratory. The State Water Board contracted with the Moss Landing Marine Laboratory to establish an expert panel to address issues associated with potential effects of discharge diffusers on marine life and provide a further explanation of the mitigation ‘fee’ approach for the entrainment impacts caused by surface intakes at desalination facilities. The panel members are Dr. Michael Foster, Dr. Gregor Cailliet, Dr. John Callaway, Dr. Kristina Mead Vetter, Dr. Peter Raimondi, and Dr. Philip Roberts.
Salinity Toxicity Studies
Researchers at the Marine Pollution Studies Laboratory at Granite Canyon determined the tolerance of Ocean Plan test species to various concentrations of hyper-saline brine. Toxicity tests followed U.S. EPA methods. The results of the tests were used to calculate no observed effect concentrations (NOECs), lowest observed effect concentrations (LOECs), and median lethal or median effects concentrations (LC50 or EC50) for each test protocol and endpoint. Toxicity tests were also conducted using brine effluent samples from a desalination facility.
- Hyper-Salinity Toxicity Thresholds for Nine California Ocean Plan Toxicity Test Protocols
Expert Panel II on Intake Impacts and Mitigation
The State Water Board contracted with the Moss Landing Marine Laboratory to establish an expert panel to address issues associated with minimizing and mitigating intake impacts from power plants and desalination facilities. The panel members were Dr. Michael Foster, Dr. Greg Cailliet, Dr. Jim Callaway, Dr. Pete Raimondi, and Mr. John Steinbeck. The panel met on August 8, 2011 and on November 15, 2011. A public meeting was held March 1, 2012 at the Moss Landing Marine where panel members presented their recommendations and took questions and comments from the public on the panel’s Draft Report. Updates were given on the other two studies. The panel members deliberated and made changes to their report, which was finalized on March 14, 2012 Expert Review Panel on Intakes: Final Report.
Expert Panel I on Impacts and Effects of Brine Discharges
The State Water Board contracted with the Southern California Coastal Water Research Project (SCCWRP) to establish a panel of experts in the fields of oceanography, plume modeling, ecotoxicology, and marine ecology to answer the following questions related to brine discharge:
- What are the potential environmental impacts?
- What disposal strategies will minimize impacts from brine discharges?
- What models should be applied to predict how brine plumes will behave?
- Can cumulative water quality effects associated with multiple brine plumes be evaluated with models?
- What are appropriate monitoring strategies for brine discharges?
A public meeting was held July 5, 2011 in Sacramento to describe the project and solicit input regarding panel members and issues. The panel met several times to develop recommendations for the State Water Board. The panel released a draft report , solicited input from the public, and held a public meeting on December 8-9, 2011. The panel met again in February 2012 and a submitted a Final Report with their findings and recommendations to the State Water Board. The related materials can be found on the SCCWRP website.
Studies Submitted to the State Water Board
West Basin Municipal Water District (WBMWD) High-Salinity Sensitivity Study
The WBMWD High Salinity Sensitivity Study evaluated the potential short-term and long-term exposure effects of high salinity discharges from the WBMWD Ocean Water Desalination Demonstration Facility (OWDDF) on aquatic organisms representative of communities indigenous to various near shore environments in Southern California. Short-term effects were evaluated using Whole Effluent Toxicity (WET) bioassays developed by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency to quantify the magnitude and threshold of potential biological effects of discharges (e.g. treated wastewater). Both acute toxicity (mortality effects) and chronic toxicity (mortality + sub-lethal effects) bioassays were performed by a state accredited bioassay laboratory. Long-term effects were evaluated using mesocosm procedures performed at the OWDDF by exposing multiple organisms for eight weeks to ambient seawater and diluted brine flows from the OWDDF in large aquaria constructed to simulate the OWDDF discharge environment.
- High-Salinity Sensitivity Study Short-and Long-Term Exposure Assessments
Questions or Comments?
- Kimberly Tenggardjaja, Statewide Policies and Planning Unit – email: Kimberly.Tenggardjaja@waterboards.ca.gov or phone 916.341.5473
- Claire Waggoner, Statewide Policies and Planning Unit Chief – email: Claire.Waggoner@waterboards.ca.gov or phone 916.341.5582